Why start a centrifugal pump with the delivery valve closed?

Stefan Weidner8 min read
Other ManufacturerOther TopicTechnical Reference
Licensed PE Working through this on a live machine? A Maine-licensed engineer can take it from here — included with IMD hardware, by the hour for everything else. Book an engineer

A centrifugal pump gains head only inside the impeller and the diffuser or volute, so every start-up, sizing, and casing question traces to one path: suction vessel, suction line, impeller eye, vane passages, casing, delivery valve. Trace that path hop by hop, and the standard interview-style questions (blade type, valve position, NPSH, dummy stage, diffuser versus volute) answer themselves.

Where does the liquid gain or lose energy on the way from suction vessel to delivery valve?

Hop What happens Governing quantity Failure if wrong
Suction vessel to suction nozzle Liquid loses head to friction and elevation change NPSHA Cavitation at the impeller eye
Impeller eye Local pressure drops to its minimum NPSHr of the impeller Vapor bubbles form, collapse in the vanes
Impeller vanes Shaft work becomes velocity and pressure Speed, diameter, blade angle Head below curve if the impeller is trimmed or worn
Diffuser or volute Flow area grows, velocity head converts to pressure head Casing geometry Efficiency loss, radial load away from the design point
Discharge nozzle to delivery valve System resistance sets the operating point System curve Operation far from BEP, recirculation, overload

Energy enters only at the impeller. Everything downstream either converts it (casing) or consumes it (piping, valves), and everything upstream must supply enough absolute pressure to keep the liquid from flashing.

Why does head stay the same when the liquid changes from kerosene to gasoline?

Head is energy per unit weight of liquid, expressed as a column height, and the impeller imparts it as a function of speed and geometry. It does not depend on specific gravity. Pressure does:

P = rho * g * H

Same head, lower density, lower discharge pressure. Absorbed power also scales with density at the same flow, so the motor load drops with the lighter liquid. Head staying constant does not make the change harmless: gasoline has a different vapor pressure and viscosity than kerosene, so recalculate NPSHA before accepting the new service. A higher vapor pressure at pumping temperature reduces NPSHA directly.

Why is the delivery valve fully closed at start, and how long can it stay closed?

A radial-flow centrifugal pump has its lowest power demand at zero flow, and power rises as the valve opens. Starting against a closed valve keeps the motor's starting load and acceleration time low, and it avoids a sudden flow surge into the discharge system. Then open the valve gradually once the motor is at speed.

Condition Effect Action
Closed valve, pump at speed All shaft power becomes heat in the casing liquid; the casing temperature climbs Open the valve promptly; take the minimum continuous flow value from the datasheet
Open valve at start Higher motor current, longer acceleration, possible water hammer on a filling line Only where the driver and system are designed for it
Mixed-flow or axial-flow pump Power at shutoff can be higher than at design flow, which reverses the rule Read the power curve before choosing the start position

The closed-valve rule is a property of the pump's power curve, not a universal law. Read the curve for the pump in front of you.

Which impeller blade and casing type give the best efficiency?

Backward-curved (bent-backward) blades give the highest efficiency among the blade types. The casing converts velocity head into pressure head by enlarging the flow area, and two arrangements do it:

Feature Volute casing Diffuser casing
Construction Spiral passage, flow area grows gradually Stationary ring with vanes around the impeller
Conversion Velocity head to pressure head by area increase Same principle, guided by vanes
Typical use Single-stage pumps Multistage pumps, where it raises efficiency at impeller exit
Cost position Economical for a single stage Not economical for a single-stage pump

A single volute develops uneven radial pressure around the impeller away from the design flow, which is why the single-versus-double-volute question comes up. A double volute balances that load at the cost of a more complex casting. The casing type sets bearing and shaft loading; verify against the vendor's radial load data.

How do you raise NPSHA or lower NPSHr?

Absolute pressure at the impeller eye must stay above vapor pressure with margin. With head units and the suction vessel surface at absolute pressure P_s:

NPSHA = (P_s - P_v) / (rho * g) + z - h_f

Here z is the liquid level above the pump centerline (negative for suction lift), h_f is suction-line friction loss, and P_v is the vapor pressure at pumping temperature. Use the minimum level and the dirtiest-strainer condition for the worst case.

Goal Measure
Raise NPSHA Raise the liquid level or lower the pump; pressurize the suction vessel; upsize suction pipe; remove fittings and keep strainers clean; cool the liquid to lower P_v
Lower NPSHr Larger impeller eye; inducer; lower speed; double-suction impeller; a booster pump upstream

Vapor pressure also drives seal selection: the stuffing-box pressure must keep the seal faces' liquid film above vapor pressure, so a high-P_v product needs a seal plan with an adequate pressure margin. Stuffing-box pressure differs between overhung (OH), between-bearings (BB), and vertical (VS) pumps because of the different leakage paths and balance arrangements; take the value from the vendor's calculation for the specific model.

How do the affinity laws and the system curve set the operating point?

The affinity laws scale a known pump curve with speed N (and, approximately, with impeller diameter D for small trims):

Q2/Q1 = N2/N1
H2/H1 = (N2/N1)^2
P2/P1 = (N2/N1)^3

The system curve does not start from zero because static head exists at zero flow:

H_system = H_static + K * Q^2

The operating point is the intersection of the pump curve and this curve. Throttling the delivery valve raises K and moves the point left along the pump curve; a speed change moves the pump curve itself. Where the intersection sits relative to the best efficiency point decides bearing life and vibration. The preferred and allowable operating ranges are datasheet and API 610 items, so read them from the edition your purchase specification invokes.

What limits viscosity, bearing temperature, and stage count?

  • Viscosity. The quoted upper limit for a centrifugal pump is 3300 cP. Head, flow, and efficiency all derate as viscosity rises, so apply the vendor's viscosity correction before relying on the water curve, and expect to move to a positive displacement pump at or beyond that limit.
  • Forced bearing cooling. The trigger given is process temperature above 205 °C, with ambient above 55 °C as the second condition. The wording does not say whether both must be present or either one suffices, so confirm the rule in the bearing-housing cooling clause of the API 610 edition in your specification and on the datasheet.
  • Hot-climate motor duty. High ambient temperature reduces the motor's thermal margin. Compare the site ambient with the nameplate ambient and insulation class, and get the derating from the motor manufacturer rather than assuming a percentage.
  • Dummy stage. A multistage pump with a dummy stage keeps a stage position empty so an impeller can be added later if the required pressure rises. It is a future-capacity provision, separate from any balancing device.

Which API 610 items come from the datasheet, not from memory?

Several common questions have numeric answers that vary by edition and by purchase specification. Look them up; do not quote them.

Item Where to read it
Vibration limit API 610 vibration clause for the edition invoked, plus the datasheet
Nozzle load allowance (including the practice of asking for 2x the API values) API 610 nozzle load table; project specification for any multiplier
Six-point performance test API 610 performance test clause and the test procedure agreed with the vendor
Minimum bearing life, hydrodynamic bearing threshold API 610 bearing clauses and the vendor's bearing calculation
Motor margin, end-of-curve (EOC) motor sizing API 610 motor sizing clause; the datasheet states which case the motor covers
MAWP, casing classification, NDT scope, seal MOC Casing datasheet, project material class, seal datasheet and seal plan
Published versus rated efficiency Vendor performance curve and the tolerance stated in the test clause

How do you verify a centrifugal pump start-up against these limits?

  1. Confirm the datasheet liquid data: density, viscosity, and vapor pressure at pumping temperature, matched to the liquid actually in the line.
  2. Calculate NPSHA at minimum liquid level with a fouled strainer, and compare it with NPSHr at maximum flow.
  3. Prime and vent the casing. Open the suction valve fully, and leave the delivery valve fully closed.
  4. Start the pump and read the shutoff discharge pressure. It must equal the curve's shutoff head times rho * g for the actual liquid.
  5. Open the delivery valve gradually while watching motor current, casing temperature, and suction pressure for cavitation noise or pressure oscillation.
  6. At the operating point, convert discharge pressure minus suction pressure to head and plot it on the pump curve. Record vibration and bearing temperatures against the datasheet limits.
  7. At the highest flow the system can demand, compare motor current with the nameplate full-load current.

FAQ

Can I start a centrifugal pump with the delivery valve open?

Only if the driver is sized for the higher power at open-valve flow and the discharge system tolerates a flow surge. For a radial-flow pump, the closed-valve start gives the lowest motor load, and for mixed-flow or axial pumps you must read the power curve first.

Does pump head change when the liquid changes from kerosene to gasoline?

No, head is independent of specific gravity, but discharge pressure follows P = rho * g * H and absorbed power follows density. Recheck NPSHA, because gasoline has a different vapor pressure.

Can a centrifugal pump run continuously against a closed delivery valve?

No. With zero flow, all shaft power heats the liquid in the casing, and recirculation loads the bearings and seal. Keep flow above the minimum continuous flow value on the datasheet.

Does a diffuser casing suit a single-stage pump?

Rarely. A diffuser raises efficiency at impeller exit and fits multistage pumps, but it is not economical for a single stage, where a spiral volute converts velocity head to pressure head at lower cost.

Can a centrifugal pump handle a 3300 cP liquid?

3300 cP is the quoted upper limit for a centrifugal pump, and head, flow, and efficiency derate well before it. Apply the vendor's viscosity correction to the curve, and consider a positive displacement pump at or beyond the limit.

Back to blog