IMDTouchKnowledge BaseShop main store

Comparison

WinCC Explorer vs Advanced, Professional, Flexible and Unified

HMI and touchscreens Published 8 min read

Short answer

WinCC Explorer is only the project shell of WinCC Classic, the pre-TIA Portal PC SCADA system. Advanced and Professional are TIA Portal products — Advanced for panel-style visualization and Runtime Advanced on a PC, Professional for data-heavy PC SCADA — Flexible is Advanced's out-of-date predecessor, and Unified is the web-based generation on Linux-based panels. For a new S7-1200 SCADA, engineer it in TIA Portal as WinCC Professional or Unified; the S7-300 SIMATIC Manager plus Explorer path does not carry over.

On this page
  1. What each name actually is
  2. WinCC Classic: what Explorer actually opens
  3. WinCC flexible: the panel line before TIA Portal
  4. Advanced and Professional: one editor, two runtimes
  5. Unified: the web-based generation
  6. Choosing by target, with the arithmetic that sizes it
  7. Rebuilding your training loop around an S7-1200
  8. Prove the link with arithmetic, not impressions
  9. Questions asked

WinCC Explorer is not one edition among several: it is the project shell of WinCC Classic, the pre-TIA Portal PC SCADA system you trained on, and none of the other names open it or use it. WinCC Advanced and WinCC Professional are TIA Portal products for panels and PC runtimes, WinCC flexible is the out-of-date predecessor of the Advanced line, and WinCC Unified is the web-based generation on Linux-based panels. These are separate platforms, not license tiers of one program. For your S7-1200 the committed path is to engineer the controller and the SCADA station together in TIA Portal — WinCC Professional for a Classic-style SCADA, or Unified for a web-based one — and to simulate the pair on one PC with the HMI simulation coupled to S7-PLCSIM.

What each name actually is #

Five names, four platforms. WinCC Classic belongs to the SIMATIC Manager era, WinCC flexible carried the panel line until TIA Portal replaced it, Advanced and Professional live inside TIA Portal, and Unified is the successor generation. Project files do not move between them. The three toolchains behind Classic, flexible and TIA are laid out side by side in WinCC V7.4, WinCC Flexible 2008 and TIA Portal compared.

Name Engineering tool Runtime target Role
WinCC Classic WinCC Explorer, its own installation WinCC runtime on a Windows PC station The original SCADA system, also the visualization layer of PCS 7
WinCC flexible WinCC flexible, SIMATIC Manager era OP, MP and TP panels, early KTP panels, flexible Runtime on a PC Predecessor of the TIA panel line; final release predates TIA Portal
WinCC Advanced TIA Portal Basic and Comfort panels, WinCC Runtime Advanced on a PC Panel-class visualization for one machine or line
WinCC Professional TIA Portal Everything Advanced engineers, plus WinCC Runtime Professional on a PC SCADA class: large data volumes, archiving, scripting
WinCC Unified TIA Portal Unified Comfort Panels, Unified PC runtime stations Web-based visualization with responsive screens

Whatever the platform, the runtime does the operator's half of how an HMI and a PLC divide the work in a control system: it reads tags, draws screens and writes setpoints, while the controller owns the logic and the safe state.

WinCC Classic: what Explorer actually opens #

Explorer is the tree-view environment where a WinCC Classic project is built: tags, driver connections and graphics live there, and the compiled project runs as WinCC runtime on a Windows station. Classic is the original WinCC used in SCADA and PCS 7 applications, and it pairs naturally with the S7-300 and S7-400 world of SIMATIC Manager. Current WinCC V7 releases do include a dedicated S7-1200 channel in the S7 driver, so an existing Classic plant can add an S7-1200 line — but the classic S7-PLCSIM that runs under SIMATIC Manager simulates S7-300 and S7-400 only, so your simulate-everything-on-one-PC loop has no Classic equivalent with an S7-1200. Decision: stay on Classic when you extend a plant that already runs WinCC V7, after confirming the installed release lists the S7-1200 channel; do not start a new S7-1200 SCADA there.

WinCC flexible: the panel line before TIA Portal #

WinCC flexible, in its 2008 release generation, engineered the OP, MP and TP panels and the early KTP generation, and it could also run a flexible Runtime on a PC. It is the direct predecessor of the TIA panel engineering that Advanced now covers. flexible projects do not open in TIA Portal; they migrate, in a one-way conversion whose scope depends on the TIA release, as described in How to migrate a WinCC flexible project to TIA Portal. Decision: touch flexible only to keep an installed legacy panel running or to move its project forward.

Advanced and Professional: one editor, two runtimes #

Advanced and Professional are engineered in the same TIA Portal editor, and inside TIA Portal the levels do escalate: a Professional license engineers everything the Advanced level engineers, plus the SCADA runtime. What decides a project is the runtime behind the name. Professional exists to manage and monitor large data volumes; Advanced is the more limited, panel-class product. Runtime Advanced puts panel-style visualization on a PC; Runtime Professional is the PC SCADA runtime that carries the archives.

The two PC runtimes are not interchangeable at the driver level either: Runtime Advanced and Runtime Professional support different communication drivers, and there is no common driver for both runtimes, so a project aimed at one runtime is reconfigured, not reused, on the other. Match the runtime version configured in the project to the runtime installed on the station as well — the version-mismatch failure is what Run a TIA Portal V14 HMI on WinCC Runtime Advanced walks through. Decision: panels or a small PC visualization, Advanced; a central station with archives and heavy tag counts, Professional.

Unified: the web-based generation #

WinCC Unified is engineered in TIA Portal too, but it is not a higher level of Advanced and Professional; it is a different runtime architecture. Screens are served to web clients, layouts are responsive and adjust to the screen they land on, and the Unified Comfort Panels at the machine are Linux-based — a large jump from the Windows CE heritage of the flexible and Comfort panels. Unified PC runtime stations also exist, and Where WinCC Unified runtime can run and remote HMI options covers the valid hosts and the remote paths.

One physical detail from the Siemens Unified migration guide: the cutouts of the 15, 19 and 22 inch Unified Comfort Panels are smaller than those of the corresponding Comfort Panels, so a Comfort opening can be kept when a Unified panel replaces it. Decision: choose Unified when you want browser clients and current panels on a new build, and budget a conversion project for any Classic or flexible content, because nothing opens across.

Choosing by target, with the arithmetic that sizes it #

Count what each station must do, then pick the platform whose runtime target matches:

  • Existing WinCC V7 plant with S7-300 or S7-400 cores: stay on Classic, and confirm the S7-1200 channel before adding that controller family.
  • Local machine interfaces on panels, plus at most a small PC visualization: Advanced.
  • One supervisory PC station with archiving and high tag counts across several controllers: Professional.
  • New build with browser clients and current panels: Unified.
  • Installed OP, MP, TP or early KTP panels: flexible, until you migrate them forward.

Worked example, with illustrative inputs — your plant supplies the real ones. Two lines, one S7-1200 each, a Comfort panel per line, and one supervisory PC. The supervisory station reads 1,800 tags from line A and 2,700 from line B, so it carries 1,800 + 2,700 = 4,500 tags. Of those, 100 are archived once per second: 100 × 86,400 = 8,640,000 values per day, and 8,640,000 × 30 = 259,200,000 values over a 30-day run. That archive load is Professional territory; the two panels carry their own embedded runtime and need no PC runtime license. The scope is therefore one Professional engineering license, one Runtime Professional license for the PC, and two panels, all engineered in a single TIA Portal project. The station itself is ordinary computer hardware; where it stands at the machine as a touchscreen, industrial panel PCs are the class that hosts it.

Rebuilding your training loop around an S7-1200 #

SIMATIC Manager cannot engineer an S7-1200, so the exercise moves wholesale into TIA Portal:

  1. Create the TIA Portal project with the S7-1200 and its logic. Compile it, load it into S7-PLCSIM, and watch a value change in the online view to confirm the controller executes.
  2. Add the HMI station to the same project: a PC station with WinCC Runtime Professional for the SCADA version of your exercise, or a Unified station for the web-based version.
  3. Create the controller connection from the HMI station to the S7-1200 inside TIA Portal. If a real controller comes later, enable remote access for the HMI in the controller's protection settings.
  4. Start the HMI simulation. TIA Portal couples it with the running S7-PLCSIM instance, which is the S7-1200 replacement for your S7-300 arrangement.
  5. Before importing a full tag list, bring up three diagnostic tags: one fast-cycling read, one known constant, and one noncritical write.

Two programs running on one PC is not by itself a passed test. Check the connection status and the quality of each diagnostic tag, because a plausible number with bad quality is still a failed link.

Use the S7 analog convention as the reference number: 0 to 27,648 counts spans 0 to 100 percent of an analog value. Configure a test tag for a 0–10 bar pressure display with an internal range of 0 to 27,648 counts, so the scale is 27,648 ÷ 10 = 2,764.8 counts per bar.

Write 5.0 bar from the screen: the runtime must place 27,648 × 5.0 ÷ 10.0 = 13,824 counts in the controller, and the S7-PLCSIM online view must show exactly 13,824. In the other direction, force 20,736 counts in the controller and the screen must read 20,736 ÷ 2,764.8 = 7.5 bar. If both directions match, the scaling and the communication link are proven at the same time.

Do the write test on the simulated controller, or on a tag that drives nothing on a running machine — a setpoint written into live logic is a production event, not a test.

Questions asked

Is WinCC Explorer required to build a SCADA system today?

No. WinCC Explorer only opens WinCC Classic projects. A TIA Portal project with WinCC Professional or WinCC Unified is a complete SCADA system and never touches Explorer, so Explorer is never installed as part of those. Build in Explorer only when you are extending an existing WinCC V7 installation that must stay on that platform.

Can I open my old WinCC flexible project directly in TIA Portal?

No, but TIA Portal converts it in a migration step. The step is one-way and release-dependent: the flexible project is first opened at the release your TIA version supports, then converted, and objects with no equivalent come back on a report instead of being converted. Archive the original, because the conversion cannot be undone.

Do WinCC Runtime Advanced and WinCC Runtime Professional use the same drivers?

No. Runtime Advanced and Runtime Professional support different communication drivers, and there is no common driver for both runtimes. A station aimed at one runtime is re-created for the other, with connections configured against the new runtime's driver list; the screens are the part that survives with the least rework.

Will a Unified Comfort Panel drop into the cutout of an older Comfort Panel?

For the 15, 19 and 22 inch sizes, the Unified Comfort Panel cutout is smaller than the Comfort Panel cutout, so the existing opening can be kept when you replace the panel. The size difference still has to be closed per the migration instructions, and you should compare the exact dimensions for your size before choosing the replacement.

Which WinCC product should I choose for a new S7-1200 SCADA with simulation on one PC?

WinCC Professional inside TIA Portal. The S7-1200 is engineered and simulated there, the HMI station is engineered in the same project, and TIA Portal's simulation couples the HMI runtime to the simulated controller on one PC. Choose Unified instead when you want browser clients and Unified Comfort Panels and have no existing project content to carry across.

Keep reading

  • Comparison

    WinCC vs WinCC Flexible for small PC SCADA applications

    WinCC Flexible can build a small SCADA application that runs on a PC, but only the Advanced edition does it — Standard stops at operator panels. Treat two decisions separately: the Advanced engineering license buys the PC runtime capability, and each PC that runs the finished application still needs its own runtime license. Beyond single-station scope, the WinCC family is the SCADA tool.

    HMI and touchscreens

  • Comparison

    WinCC V7.4, WinCC Flexible 2008 and TIA Portal Compared

    WinCC V7.x is PC-based SCADA software, WinCC Flexible 2008 engineers operator panels and single PC stations and is discontinued as a standalone tool, and WinCC inside TIA Portal is the successor engineering platform alongside STEP 7. Decide by the target device and the exact project files on your engineering workstation, not by the shared WinCC name. STEP 7 is the PLC tool, not a WinCC product.

    HMI and touchscreens

  • Explainer

    Why a PSB Backup Cannot Run in WinCC Flexible PC Runtime

    No. A .psb file is a ProSave device image that restores only to the panel model it came from, and Siemens documents that it cannot be loaded or edited in the engineering tool. To run the application on a PC, open the source .hmi project, change the device type to the PC runtime, recompile and license it.

    HMI and touchscreens